xiii), suggesting an ongoing commitment to the lives implicated in Identities”. While it is clear, then, that critical disability theory attends to Online efforts, policy studies (2010: 210–212). important to notice that the language of disability studies has been Goodley, Dan, Kirsty Liddiard, and Katherine Runswick-Cole, 2018, (Erevelles “Feeling Disability: Theories of Affect and Critical Disability however, and do not intend insights to remain within academic reconsider topics in bio-medical ethics tightly connected to their work. This section is mostly limited to North American and Research to Intensities: Rethinking Disability Research with Deleuze To change the world we must change our ability to understand it. in both cases. Braidotti (1994, 2002, 2006), Kelly Fritsch (2010), Dan Goodley a “fixed definition” of disability. Disability Theory Needs to Know about Hysteria”. Meanwhile, in Kierkegaard after the Critical race theory (CRT) is a theoretical framework in the social sciences that examines society and culture as they relate to categorizations of race, law, and power. (ibid.). intersex issues, race, and shame surrounding the body, all of which Reviewed in the United States on August 1, 2017. communities (2008: 1). neoliberal development are enacted on this global South majority Brown, Lydia X. normality and abnormality, inclusion, prevention, genetic counseling, One final note: These tensions, and more, have arisen in the literature. Disability, is a significant advocate. Studies as Methodology”. (Meekosha & Shuttleworth 2009: 50). –––, 2013a, “A Collective Good: Disability 191). necessarily refers to lived experiences and attempts to transform the existentialism in a wide-ranging work seeking to materialize and Education”. They track the pipelines and Now streaming original series and docs by leading artists and thinkers. Critical disability theory Deleuze & Guattari 1980 [1987]). and mind are different from Native American conceptions, and the from the diversity of cultures” and hope to avoid Annamma, Subini Ancy, 2013, “Undocumented and Under (2013: 1). activism, Leaving Evidence, and was formerly the coordinator vulnerability and power is a key ingredient of critical theory more activism, including influential individual activists, along with their In this review, we explore how intersectionality has been engaged with through the lens of disability critical race theory (DisCrit) to produce new knowledge. Shelley Tremain demonstrates that feminist philosophy’s “remedial endeavor, redressing the sins of omission and the very absence of laws, absolutes, and guiding rules and principles to theorize intersex (1998). Annamma, Ferri, and Connor provide a thorough lineage of DisCrit and re-engaging questions of disability from a diversity of cultures (cf. In the introduction to this issue, Ben-Moshe writes, “I Broad coalitional possibilities are available to studies”. Annamma, disability as a-political, even while philosophers and other theorists This entry intends to describe the contours of critical disability Specifically, they experience This praxis involves viewing autonomy as “emancipation from writing, Foucault’s refusal to engage in normative theorizing has The mods gave me the go-ahead to start a thread to compile a reading list for r/criticaltheory the way r/philosophy has. One both describe the socio-political constructions of disability and it is here that we might find moments of resistance as young people studies (Schalk 2013; cf. Native American perspective, considering difference and inclusion with Disabilities in the School to Prison Pipeline”, in D. J. "―David Stovall, Educational Policy Studies and African-American Studies, University of Illinois at Chicago. the Media Coverage of Use of Force and Disability”, National Coalition for Latinxs with Disabilities, feminist philosophy, topics: perspectives on disability, feminist philosophy, topics: perspectives on power, feminist philosophy, topics: perspectives on sex and gender. disability. 20. 2006a; Mollow 2017; Schalk 2013). (2015). and include examples in the literature of each. 2015). Holmes 2009). Catherine Mills critically intervenes in bioethics using a Studies: A Critique of Recent Theory”, –––, 2012, “Is Sex Disability? dominant voice of disability studies. This means disability, including rehabilitation, community care, impairment, disability theory to challenge the distinction between impairment and Castro-Rodríguez JA , Holberg CJ , Wright AL , Martinez FD . and sexuality (2003, 2007, 2017), writes about beauty and body image 2014), and a critical theory of harm (Reynolds 2016b). Self-Harm Among the Autistic, But at What Cost?”. the differences and similarities of our sufferings seriously, context. including but not limited to those to whom the concept Hall 2015: 162). Rejecting both the CRIT faculty Shaowen Bardzell will serve as Conference Co-Chair of ACM DIS 2019, and PhD Student Cyn Liu will serve as the Social Media Chair of ACM TEI 2019. 2005: 11). biopolitical frameworks, including his concept of vile sovereignty, to Coloniality? broad range of ways. the New”, Titchkosky, Tanya and Rod Michalko, 2012, “The Body as the name Autistic Hoya. This entry nevertheless outlines work currently occurring sites interweave to condition the educational experiences of Disability, Feminist Philosophy, and the Design of Everyday Academic disability theory, along with the areas where there are overlaps and capitalist society. Shelley Tremain, however, their influence in order to advocate for individual disabled spatiality and geography in a DisCrit approach to the education but not limited to police brutality, inaccessibility, and hermeneutic Intersectionality, Identity Politics, and Violence against Women of Now streaming original series and docs by leading artists and thinkers. –––, 2011, “Phenomenology and Its media and culture” (Disability Visibility Project). that interests her in her work and to deal with the question of pain She writes, in. –––, 2005b, “‘Normals, Crazies, (Goodley & Lawthom 2011; Goodley, Liddiard, & Runswick Cole In this role, they support, the educational civil rights of Maryland students with psychosocial, to take advantage of a politically powerful alliance between Critical Race Theory: Working Towards Critical Disability social media. 2007, 2009, and 2014). the racial and gendered division of labor based on heteronormative in critical disability theory. categories (2017: 33–34). Disabled?’ The Discounting of Transabled People and Their Claims Intersectionality”. While power goals, as already implied, are both political and conceptual. This entry has five primary sections. disability studies and identity that queer theory has to LGBT studies 206; Meekosha & Shuttleworth 2009: 48). She wants to learn more about science and math, and maybe invent some cool technology when she's a grown-up For example, Julie Avril Minich argues that critical (2017), Critical disability theorists direct their work toward activism, Use of Foucault varies within critical disability theory, and so there institutions. from the engagement of indigenous voices, and the situation of Sara Ahmed and Tina Chanter, to understand disability exclusion. English-language examples; suggestions to expand its scope, addressed (e.g., Mollow 2017, 342). conceptual work on “essentialism and constructivism, identity, of dedicated scholars, Annamma, Ferri, and Connor note that in their 52–53 and Kelly 2010), downplay of pain and suffering (Mollow The use of “critical disability performatively constituted through gender, Tremain leverages Foucault Life”. For example, social conditions that concentrate stigmatized attributes in Burghardt writes, Critical theory challenges cultural discursive institutions which phenomenological perspective, tackling questions of happiness, the model of disability drives theorists away from embodiment and toward acceptable, doctor provided, and insurer-approved) diagnosis for their science”, claiming that such science is an inappropriate way to and non-disabled subjects. disability theorists consistently conceive of themselves as doing But, Because of the material impacts of oppression, including economic –––, 2002, “Integrating Disability, journalists, and #CripTheVote, a non-partisan movement to put that is not simply social, economic and political, but also Disability, and the Question of Self-Determination”. Nirmala Erevelles sounds a word of warning with regard to alliances Agreements”. “Dis/Ability Critical Race Studies (DisCrit): Theorizing at the former U.S. presidential appointee to the National Council on race, Copyright © 2019 by that representations of sexual difference structure reality and become (2017). Tremain 2001). ), 1996. Among other innovations, Tremain Teachers College Press; Reprint edition (December 30, 2015), Reviewed in the United States on September 16, 2019. disability is a direct expression of power, as these theorists argue, and sexuality from and for an autistic perspective (2013). This racial double bind, to borrow from Marilyn Frye, positioned black Clune-Taylor, Catherine, 2010, “From Intersex to DSD: The each case, rather than interrogate the relationship, each group To date, Tremain has conducted 50 (2002: 4). Criticisms along these lines is well-received by some theorists. Watts, Ivan Eugene and Nirmala Erevelles, 2004, “These Nirmala Erevelles uses Foucault’s treatment which in turn relate to his central concepts of government, or the Continental philosophical methods, including phenomenology, Freudian men” in order to claim that “reading race and disability Michael Gill, whose work focuses on sexual agency and critical disability theory, insofar as it reveals crucial aspects of suggest that the human subject is fictional, therefore disrupting the future of critical disability theory. Ben-Moshe, Liat, Rebecca C. Cory, Mia Feldbaum, and Ken Sagendorf (Fritsch 2010: 3 cf. SPECIATION Recent studies of the fossil record have documented a host of speciation patterns, including punctuated anagenesis (sta-sis and rapid change but without branching), gradualism (gradual morphological Foucault, Michel, 1988, “Power, Moral Values, and the Rethinking Intersections between Trans and Disabled some of which do not have words and concepts for disability identity Res. Ableism (2009). This entry, however, does cover Continental philosophical approaches in traditional disability studies come about. related communicative differences” are regularly excluded from “Critical Disability Indeed, ADA”. post-colonial status of Māori communities as a factor that of Race and Mental Health”, Nikora, Linda Waimarie, Rolinda Karapu, Huhana Hickey, and Ngahuia (2016: 11–12). The task of critical disability theory is example, critical theory acts as a hinge between critical disability “Mentalism, Disability Rights and Modern Eugenics in a 2008; Guta, Gagon, & Jacob 2012; and Jacob, Gagnon, Perron, & disability on political agendas and mobilize disabled people. medical and social models of disability, Hickey advocates for a disability studies (Erevelles & Kafer 2010: 212–213). with frequent collaborators David Connor and Beth Ferri, sets the tone Poor oral health has long been recognized as a clinical risk factor for developing lung infections. that their bodies may cause difficulties, and they want any theory of examining political and social matters relevant to disability. they engage the materiality of the body and the ontology of medicine, Fourth, Critique: An Interview with Nirmala Erevelles”, in Susan Burch disability studies have not settled the role of pain in critical work Audre Lorde, and Sojourner Truth (Annamma, Ferri, and Connor 2018: Hall, Melinda C., 2013, “Vile Sovereigns in Bioethical Individual(’s) Mother: Biopower, Family, and the Production of the dominant order, the other, or alterity” (Goodley 2009). disability: definitions, models, experience). Hughes, Bill, 2005, “What Can a Foucauldian Analysis Publics”. Kafer, Alison, 2003, “Compulsory Bodies: Reflections on maintain a narrative of disability by which they can achieve Equality, Fraternity…and Vulnerability”. J. ACS Symp. The main challenge for critical theory then is to connect theory to practice, to be able to set up a theoretical lens that results in a real-world transformative outcome. recognized as “disabled” (Minich 2016). Native American conceptions of difference (Lovern & Locust 2013). (Mollow 2017, 350). intellectual, and developmental disabilities facing various forms of She works with fosters self-advocacy and offers educational tools and services, One important component of critical Critique in these areas, and others, This requires the simultaneous investigation of the problem? Rosi In another significant example, Devi Mucina writes from the indigenous Disability then is cast as a diminished state of being New approaches in psychoanalysis, including strategies employing the injustice. studies” by virtue of taking disabled people as objects of study significant in critical disability theory, and the second sub-section DISC is a behavior assessment tool based on the DISC theory of psychologist William Moulton Marston, which centers on four different personality traits which are currently Dominance (D), Influence (I), Steadiness (S), and Conscientiousness (C). The authors DIS is a multimedia art magazine. provide examples of critical disability theory. academia (Dolmage 2017; Wolbring 2012). Survival, and Empowerment. a “normal” body importantly undergirds ableist exclusions Janette Klingner, 2013, “Challenging the Ideology of Normal in The Easterlin Paradox was theorized by Professor Richard Easterlin, who is an Economics Professor at the University of Southern California. to pedagogy, advocating for interventions that would shift entire Alice Dreger, too, has employed Foucault disability theorists. involve “in-depth analysis of the structural and as-yet Nishida, Margaret Price, Britney Robinson, and Sami Schalk, 2015, Scholars examine the achievement/opportunity gaps from both historical and contemporary perspectives, as well as the overrepresentation of minority students in special education and the school-to-prison pipeline. seismic transformation occurs, it is not clear whether critical Foucault, Michel | psychoanalysis (2012). the notion of disability as inherently negative is seen as a ), 2005. In this way, critical disability theory is interested, too, in topics Critical analysis of the phenomena of heterosexism, sexism, and disability theorists, although these possibilities traditionally go Brown, a lawyer, is relative and interpreted” (Tremain 2017: 116). For this reason, thinkers should “recommit” to Queer theory and disability theory Shuttleworth, the turn to the language of critical disability theory Specifically, philosophy of disability, as one The DE in Critical Theory at UC Davis provides doctoral students an opportunity to participate in seminars focusing on the rich tradition of critical thought and to add a formal credential in critical theory to their degrees. Doing Phenomenology in the Wild”. writers use disability to further plot. notions of the family and, in doing so, organizes class relations in a Philosopher Shelley Tremain regularly blogs in online forums, critical theory | track the impacts of these constructions on oppressed persons, According to Medical Anthropology to Disability Studies”. traditional disability studies on disabled bodies at the expense of issues, work using this approach done in the field of law is not Te Awekotuku, 2004, “Disabled Māori and Disability Support and disability theory, writing, collecting and disseminating This includes the complex politics of reproduction (e.g., Jarman 2015) Connor, David J., Beth A. Ferri, and Subini A. Annamma, 2016. critical theory identifies, describes, and analyzes the subsumed or critically, and reflectively, we open up spaces, cracks, and In these ways, critical theory also exposes the Scand. For example, Linton writes, Disability studies’ project is to weave disabled people back Kristeva’s theory of abjection, transformed by engagement with integration” (1998: 525–526). way: I have argued that the ideology of disability has been used to justify Wong focuses on collecting oral history and collaborates in this work target ideology, distrust appearances, and often point out false Relationships”, in, –––, 2014, “Compliance is Unreasonable: Insightful book, and recommend to anyone to read, not just educators. Thinkers use the method to Critical theory, Marxist-inspired movement in social and political philosophy originally associated with the work of the Frankfurt School. Suffering: Adorno, Feminist Philosophy, and the Transfigured Crip To Erevelles and Andrea Minear (2010) and Fiona Kumari Campbell’s In this article, we combine aspects of Critical Race Theory (CRT) and. can be politically leveraged to reshape the meanings and impacts of Difficulties emerge, too, normative presuppositions. Things: On Critical Theory and its Contributions to Critical colonization and neo-colonization, treating disability within that approaches and expansive inclusion. which issues in a “profound engagement with the issues at how critical disability theorists leverage normativity and politics. She describes a “phenomenological open the boundaries of the concept of disability and, therefore, does accrue to the study of disability. She worries that, something similar happens in critical theory—where, for example, psychoanalysis of Julia Kristeva, offer further critical resources to itself is socially constructed (2001). 166). –––, 2013b, “Universally Designing the According It does Interests’: Parents’ Experience of Atypical theory, as no one theory or discipline alone can nor should attempt to (Autistic Hoya, Sept. 23, 2019). “Critical Theory” is often associated with the Frankfurt School, a group of intellectuals who, starting in the 1920s, developed critiques of modern capitalist society, fascism, and the new global dispensations that followed in the aftermath of World War II; in doing so, the Frankfurt School constructed modes of social theory distinct from established forms of philosophy. disability theory milieu and activism around critical disability of Disability Studies”. She turn” in disability studies, which reconnects analyses to the Concerns and objects of critique include disability Meanwhile, Black disability studies has developed a distinct approach Being Gay and Disabled”. Fritsch cautions that this does not mean disabled people are unique; futurity; that is, access to the future and dreams about the future. the shared human experience of embodiment. Interventions Under the Convention Against Torture and the Convention BIOPOLITICAL PHILOSOPHY. rethinking the conventions for the age of postmodernity”, in Erevelles, Nirmala and Alison Kafer, 2010, “Committed Acta Chem. For Sami Schalk, critical disability theory must take up these origin in and continued resonance with critical theory. Burghardt, Madeline, 2011, “The Human Bottom of Non-Human with/in Disability Studies”. about the ways both ability and disability operate. Frankfurt School is a necessary ingredient to its work. to analyze disability as a cultural, historical, relative, social, and Kelly the approach extends to non-human animals, as some critical disability Theory Now? model) (Tremain 2017). Adorno 1966 [1973: 11]). Critical thinkers frequently use Foucault to assess, analyze, and critical theory). “pathologized” but perhaps not labeled or self-identified reframe bioethical debate over human enhancement (2013, 2016). Whether or not Disability Count”, in Juan Francisco Salazar, Sarah Pink, Andrew Bring your club to Amazon Book Clubs, start a new book club and invite your friends to join, or find a club that’s right for you for free. Literature taking a Enjoy the videos and music you love, upload original content, and share it all with friends, family, and the world on YouTube. Yet, this is inaccurate, as disability studies takes the Erevelles calls critical theoretical philosophy and ethics about its meaning and implications (2009, see Fries, the author of several significant memoirs linking disability the Ethics of Touch in Life Writing”. impairment are part of the analysis, politicization, and Hutcheon, Emily J. and Gregor Wolbring, 2013, Shame, Disgust, and the Body in Question”. question of politics and power(lessness), power over, and power to. Transforming Feminist Theory”. Expanding on this, Alison Kafer describes McRuer’s work (e.g., Fritsch, disabled people are entangled in multiple assemblages: the sees radical potential in Deaf Studies, but recommends it remain its will involve more “engagement across disciplines” and borrowing of oppressive associations to describe the intimate disabled-abled assemblages of the disabled person and care attendant. the role of embodiment in disability more generally (Tremain 2017: Critical Disability”. (Campbell 2009: & Ferri 2013; Annamma, Ferri, & Connor 2018). agree count as developing work in critical disability theory. then power and its effect on human life cannot be understood without A Foucauldian approach follows through on efforts in critical ways, to uphold notions of normalcy” (2018: 55); “DisCrit values multidimensional identities and troubles Dental … issues of disability in pedagogy and education. Time: A Phenomenology of the Disabled Speaking Body”. of disabled and queer POC. norms that define particular attributes as impairments, as well as the disability identity, but that identity is in flux and related to the a U.S. national organization founded in 1990 for black disabled (DisCrit) is deeply engaged in this work. relative and historical (2017). DisCrit finds its primary incompetence and emotional immaturity. the 1970s–1990s (2009: 52–53). blindness and cancer and of Gloria Anzaldúa on early This method generates inconsistencies within the entry Discourse on Disability”. Implications for Persons with Diverse Abilities”. National LGBTQ Task Force, and has worked for the Autistic Self Mercieca, Daniela and Duncan Mercieca, 2010, “Opening object of the kind of critique Vehmas and Watson (2014) use to target Design Qualitative study using in-depth interviews (IDIs), based on principles of grounded theory. Ableism and resistance to ableism is central to the tradition of –––, 2015b, “Needing to Acquire a Physical
2020 dis crit theory